Weird Ice Cream Toppings Taste Test

July 30, 2019 posted by

(rooster crowing) – This is Calloway. – Welcome to Good Mythical More. – Merchicality.
– Boom. – We gonna shout out to somebody who reps some of that mythical merch. And this winner this time Rapha Conrad. Rapha she is a mythical
beast if there ever was one. Congrats Rapha, you win
$30 to the – Met at Vidcon last year
and then on tour as well. All right, for this special
tasting of weird toppings on ice creams as recommended by you, I’d like to invite my
daughter and her friend to come join us. Yes, it’s bring your daughter
and her friend to work day. This is Lily, my daughter, this is Riley. – My daughter. You didn’t know I had one. – Recently adopted. – That’s weird. You don’t have to continue that, Riley. – This is just Lily’s friend,
I don’t have a daughter. I have two boys, sadly.
– Slide over that way a little bit, guys. – All right. – And then come on up,
come on up to the desk. – Okay, so. – Hello Lily.
– Hi, okay. – How are ya?
– I’m good. – You guys like ice cream? – Sure, of course. – ‘Course you do, it runs
in the family, right Riley? – Of course. – Do you, whenever Riley’s
hanging out with Lily she has all these production questions because she, like, does production. What do you do at the? You do the announcements. – I do the announcements. I’m the head anchor at our school’s news production, I guess. – Okay. – Do you use, is it like Riley, something that starts with an R,
like you have a fake name for your news anchoring. – I do not. That would be such a good idea though. – Riley Rainstorm.
– I need one. – She’s not a weather woman. – But she could be. I mean, I don’t know, she’s young. I mean, lots of life choices ahead. – So instead of continuing to field all of her questions, I was like, “Lily, just bring her in. “Just let her, let her drill Morgan.” – Let Morgan answer all the questions. I did see Morgan doing that. – [Director] The phrasing of that. Link you have a particularly white hair that is on your darker
hairs that is on your left. – C’mon Lily, help me out. – Oh, oh, gosh, Link.
– What? – I saw it when you turned.
– What, this? – Yeah, I think you got it. – [Director] Whew, thanks. – You guys agree with
the drumstick winning? – Oh yeah, totally, I was
cheering for it behind the. – The curtain?
– The curtain. – Behind the scenes.
– Yeah, behind the scenes. – When was the last time
you guys got somethin’ from an ice cream truck. – Like, never. – Well, I don’t allow that in my home. – Well, mom was always not very
loving of ice cream trucks. – Yeah, throw mom under
the bus or the truck. – She was suspicious. She was suspicious. She thought maybe they
had all been poisoned. – [Director] I’m sorry, you’ve
done something really great with the white hair now. – Hold on, turn, turn again. – [Director] If you wanna
just, no, don’t touch. Oh no, you’ve, you’ve ruined it. – I haven’t touched anything. – [Director] Yeah, yeah you did. Turn, turn like more to the other way. I think you did. I think you accidentally touched it. – Keep goin’, keep goin’, keep goin’. – [Director] It was like hanging like. It was like an ear piercing
that was further back. – Oh, those the best
kind of ear piercings. The ones that are just
in the scalp back here. – [Director] Oh, no, no, it’s gone now but, oh man, it was so good. Everyone in the comments can just talk about how good it was. – That’s what they’re all talking about. – Roll it back. Okay, so Katashi tweeted
“I like buttered popcorn “on chocolate ice cream. “My dad like hot sauce on all ice cream “because he doesn’t like how sweet it is.” – Okay, so do you want me to put. I don’t, I’ve got ice cream over here but you want me to put
both of these on one? – [Male Director] Chocolate and vanilla. – Okay, all right. So I would put the hot
sauce on the vanilla, right? Okay, this seems good to me, first of all. – Why?
– The way the butter. The idea of butter going with ice cream. – Sweet and salty.
– Exactly. – That’s a good combination. – It reminds me of, you know, the buttered popcorn jelly bean? – I’ve heard tell of them.
– I don’t like them, so. But that’s what this reminds me of. – All right, but they’re accurate. I think that the popcorn
flavor of that jelly bean. Just get in there. – It kinda scares me.
– Oh okay. – That’s why I don’t like it.
– It scares you? Like whales? – Okay, you know what,
we didn’t need to bring that into this. – There are, no whales
will be harmed or shown. – It’s shame your daughter at work day. – I have a phobia of whales. Just, it’s, you know.
– What’s the scientific name for that?
– Cetaphobia. – Right off the top of your head. – You’re afraid of cetus. Otherwise known as whales. That’s good, y’all.
– That was really good. – That’s actually not that bad.
– Katashi in the house. – I enjoyed that.
– That’s good. – That’s good.
– Now. – I wouldn’t have thought with chocolate. – But with chocolate’s good.
– The chocolate’s good. I don’t actually like
vanilla ice cream so. – I’m gonna do this.
– Just get like a second. – Now we.
– It’s really good. – We have some hot sauce here. – Don’t use The Last fricking Dab. That’s like, that’ll burn you. You know that, I actually just last night I put the regular Hot Ones hot sauce on some chicken, it’s so good. Their just, their regular hot
sauce from Heatonist, so good. Why don’t you give us that, Josh? Why’d you give us the
hottest one they have? – [Josh] Who me? – Listen, I’m not gonna
put that Last Dab on there. – I think you’re fine with it but. Okay, ladies, which one do you want? Tapatio or habanero hot
sauce from Trader Joe’s? – Let’s do the habanero. – All right. – Right girls? – Shake it up first. – Oh yeah, that was our
decision, definitely. – It’s not too hot, right?
– Unanimous. – [Josh] Uh, it’s like a
seven and a half out of eight. – Out of eight?
– Now Lily. – Out of eight.
– Oh gosh. – I know that you’re okay, but, I mean, you’re not, like, lactose intolerant or somethin’, are ya? – Oh, I am lactose intolerant. – Are you dad joke intolerant? – Very much so, yes. – Okay, you’re gonna have a lotta trouble. – If it has a, if it doesn’t.
– Oh I can smell that. – Have a little hole at the
top, it can’t be that hot. – [Lily] I mean, some of us. – [Link] Whales have a
little hole on the top. Oh, sorry. – I’m just putting it on.
– It’s, it’s fine. – There in, like, Smucker’s level. You know what I’m sayin’?
– Oh, that’s so gross. – Like if I would put Smucker’s on there. – Oh my gosh. Do you want a fresh spoon? We can use this.
– Yeah, let’s use a fresh spoon. – I’m not gonna eat a lot. Just gonna say that.
– Yeah, it’s, it’s gonna. – Let’s.
– This is gonna be interesting.
– Okay. So, just, you know. – [Link] You know, you
gotta get the hot sauce. There ya go. Lily. You goin’ ginger with it. – Oh gosh. – Can I have a water? – Oh god I hate this.
– Um, here. – You can have that one. – That was actually really good. – Riley’s out.
– I disagree. – Riley’s out.
– No, I’m loving this. – Lily, how are you doing?
– I’m crying now. – Okay, I, I can do the spice. It’s not that bad.
– Ooh, wow. – Riley Rainstorm’s havin’.
– The spice isn’t that bad. – A tough with it now.
– The taste is terrible. I hate it.
– Yeah. – But um.
– Riley Rutabaga’s havin’ a tough time over there. – I feel like that one’s.
– With that hot sauce. – Better than rainstorm. – Ah, it’s, it’s.
– I wanna eat. – That’s hot.
– That’s a good sauce. – I’m gonna eat more of this one. – That’s a good sauce.
– That is nasty. – I like the popcorn one.
– That was so bad. – You don’t like it?
– I do not like it. – I just can’t handle spice.
– I think, I think with more of like a Texas Pete level hot it would be even more fun. – The popcorn and
chocolate cancels it out. I would recommend going back in for that. – Not good guys. – I recommend this hot
sauce from Trader Joe’s. Not a sponsor. – Zachary Gaulke tweets, “Ranch
on top of raspberry sorbet, “the saltiness of the ranch balances out “the sweetness of the sorbet,
it is the perfect snack.” – So far.
– Is this a joke? – Katashi and her dad,
they knew what was up? – Want me to put some on there? – But Zachary.
– Oh gosh, this is gonna be fun.
– Zachary is trolling us, y’all. – Ranch is like liquified cardboard to me so we’re gonna see how this goes. – [Rhett] Have you had that as well? – Yes. It’s actually my favorite food. – I’m doing anymore. That’s already gross.
– Is that part of the announcements at school?
– Yeah. – And now I will eat
the liquified cardboard. – Today in the cafeteria we’ve got. – If they had announcements, they did have announcements when we were in school! Why didn’t we do those? – ‘Cause Veronica Swan had
a monopoly on that, man. – Didn’t Michael Juve take over? You had to be president.
– Oh, yeah. – You had to be, you had to be. – Only the president
did the announcements? – The student body president.
– The president of the United States.
– No. The student body president.
– That would be interesting. – Is the one who gave the announcements. – I didn’t think through that very well when Michael convinced
me to run for treasurer. – I ran for vice president
but I didn’t get it. All right, so, get your, get your. – [Riley] I can’t abstain? – Nope, that’s not an option.
– Okay. All right.
– Go for, like, the little bit of ranch at the top. – [Riley] Yeah. – [Link] I don’t think this’ll be. I think this could be good. – [Lily] It’s not gonna be
as bad as the hot sauce one. – That’s interesting. – I don’t like. I just, I have to have ranch
on somethin’ super savory like a french fry. – Okay, it’s not that bad. – It’s pretty.
– But it’s, but it’s bad.
– But it’s. It’s not that bad.
– I actually don’t think. – But it is that bad.
– It’s that bad. It doesn’t taste good
but it’s not that bad. – But would you do it? – I’d rather eat that
than the hot sauce one. – Would you, okay. But would you do it.
– I wouldn’t do it, like. – You would never just do it. – Like if I was eating raspberry sorbet, I wouldn’t just put ranch on it. – I think this is
somethin’ that I might do. – That is the best. – That is.
– This is good. Like, I keep going back to this one because the other ones are worse. – Okay, Matthew Dwyer, mythical employee, I think he’s rescuing us, “Frosted Flakes “on vanilla ice cream is the bomb.” – Okay, this one, this one sounds good. – We’re engaging with our
employees over social media. – Yeah, that’s the only
time we talk to Matthew. – Frosted Flakes.
– Is through Twitter on this show, he’s not even here for it. – Now, Matthew is a, he’s a
very focused guy, you know? – He’s always, he’s always in that room with the lights turned off. – Frosted Flakes is my
favorite cereal, so. – Are we gonna get any
of the ice cream because. – Yes.
– I don’t know if this is my spoon but you know. – This feels like an excellent idea. – I like the texture combination. – [Link] Yeah, you got the crunchy. – [Rhett] Oh man. – You, you want a new spoon? – It’s like, it’s like getting, like the fruity pebbles on
the frozen yogurt, you know? – You want a new spoon?
– Matthew! – I’m good, it’s fine.
– You want a new spoon? – That’s good.
– I’m gonna come in that dark room every
once in a while now. Is this what you’re doin’ in there? You just in there mixin’
cereals with ice cream? Get to work. – He’s also doing amazing graphics. – He is.
– Oh yeah. – In fact.
– That’s good. – If he, I mean, I could shoot lightning out of my fingers just like Shazam if I wanted to right now. I’m sorry, no, no, don’t do it again. Don’t do it again, ’cause
you’re tempting him. – He’s gonna get angry, Riley.
– Oh gosh. – No, but I. – That’s really good. – See, I still, I’m gonna have
to double, double dip here. Whoops. – [Rhett] That tastes exactly
like you think it does. – I would never double dip with residue. – [Director] Oh god. – Never, I would never. I would never put my residue in there. – It’s just like eating
Frosted Flakes with milk but the milk has turned into ice cream. – It’s like if you ate,
if you froze cereal milk. – Yeah.
– And then you ate it with more cereal on top. That’s kind of the vibe that
vanilla ice cream gives to me. – So what kinda things do they have on the menu at school right now? And how do you say it to the student body? – Well, we do have an ice
cream vending machine. – No, I want Riley Rutabaga to say it like she’s.
– Oh, I’m sorry. – Like, like I’m a student.
– Alright. – My daughter can answer. If my daughter wants to
answer, Rhett, she can answer. – That scared me.
– She knows the answer too. Just because she doesn’t
give the announcements doesn’t mean she doesn’t listen to ’em. – Okay.
– All right. – All right Riley.
– So, Riley, what were you sayin’? – I don’t know anymore. Well.
– Rectangular pizza. – Yeah, rectangular pizza, we’ve got, today in the cafeteria
we’ve got, usually some form of vegetable that’s not really a vegetable but it’s a vegetable
substitute so it works enough. – [Link] Is this what you say? – No. – Well that’s what you’re thinking. – You’re like.
– This is what I have. – The lunch ladies hate you.
– Say to, yeah, no. Sadly I can’t do sketch comedy, but. – What about you, Lily,
what were you gonna say? – I was gonna say we have a
ice cream vending machine. – We do. – What the crap, really? – Yeah, we have.
– I should go to your school sometimes.
– No. – We have some of the, we have the strawberry shortcake one. – Well, does it, does it like.
– Oh yeah, we have that one. – We do.
– Is it on a coil, it’s like.
– No, it’s like the packaged ones. – No.
– No, it doesn’t do that. – Doesn’t work that way.
– It’s like the packaged ones. – What do you mean the packaged ones? – Like the ones you just ate. – Yeah, they’re in a package, but then how are they delivered
through the vending machine? – Like a normal vending machine. – It like launches into a little cup. – By a man with a mustache.
– And it brings it. – Oh a cup.
– Obviously, obviously Josh is inside every single one
of our vending machines. – Yeah.
– Yeah. – [Rhett] Got some hair, got
some lips, got some stank? Get your groom on with the
Mythical Grooming Collection available now at


100 Replies to “Weird Ice Cream Toppings Taste Test”

  1. Thecanadianwitch says:

    lmao, the edits are everything

  2. TurtleDoesLife says:

    Residue GREMLIN😂😂

  3. Bob Lapish says:

    D A D E N E R G Y

  4. Maddie Joy says:

    I like mixing cinnamon into vanilla ice cream. So good.

  5. dustinallenphoto says:

    Any cereal on any ice cream is bomb!! But golden grahams is absolutely mind blowing!

  6. Pandora Kane says:

    This was a great episode! Love the gals on the show, the edits were great and Links gross residue dip tripped me up!

  7. Alyssa K says:

    i would NEVER

  8. Ashley Compton says:

    Oddly enough, Riley looks like she could be Rhett’s daughter…

  9. Mustafa Hamid says:

    Riley is cute

  10. Kat Brigman says:

    I loved that instant replay😂

  11. ChaoticMatters says:

    4:11 is such a link thing to say lol

  12. Barmelo Xanthony says:

    so nobody on that set has been to Afters lol

  13. Azure Voltic says:

    Riley is beautiful

  14. Richard Garron says:

    Rhett: "I have two boys…sadly." …And then no comment from the other three. Wow, that's just wrong!

  15. Angie Malone says:

    Tapitio is practically ketchup

  16. Angie Malone says:

    I love frosted flakes n ice cream

  17. Guadalupe Leyva says:

    Omg can you imagine if Rhett had a daughter ?

  18. lechatbotte says:

    Frosted Flakes on ice cream is like fried ice cream!

  19. Julie Elise says:

    Lily and Riley Rutabaga were great guests.

  20. XxhunnieLovexX says:

    The girls are so pretty! I for sure could picture them in something like stranger things. They have that kind of aesthetic going on 🙂

  21. Hannah Luck says:

    Lily is sooo adorable!! Cute video

  22. lao khang says:

    Wow, what an episode.

  23. Privacy Valued says:

    An entire episode where the crew double-dips and then both Rhett and Link have to consume the item anyway.

  24. - Platypus - says:

    Awwww Lily is so beautiful and so much older than the last time I saw her on the show

  25. blu Garcia says:

    Zachary is a liar😂😂😂

  26. Appo Gaming says:


  27. DJCharlieHorse says:

    try chipotle with chocolate. kinda a sweet heat.

  28. Jasmine Jones says:

    I'm really glad that Lily's back seems great after surgery. That's a huge thing to go through.

  29. The Mythical Mormon Theoristian Matthite says:

    They were amazing and beautiful new faces! Would love to see them on again

  30. Rubicant says:

    Oh gosh Lily looks like Lando ferrrr'sssurree

  31. Mennen Gordon says:

    have y’all never been to milk bar?? theres one in LA and they make “cereal milk” ice cream

  32. Taste like china had a baby and named it America says:

    im sorry but if the daughters switched places then they would look like its their dad.

  33. Sara says:

    This is entertaining thanks

  34. Austen M says:

    I wonder how David Dobrick is functioning while Natalie is busy disguising herself as a little girl that is friends with links daughter?

  35. Gavin Blanton says:

    Crushed lays chips with chocolate syrup is amazing as well!

  36. forris says:

    riley looks exactly like the girl at my school who was also the head news anchor.. same style of glasses and clothes

  37. Melba Peach says:

    Lily has become such a beautiful young lady ✨

  38. yoga pangestu says:

    Riley Rhettdaughter

  39. Megan Sandy says:

    Woah, you can tell his kids are siblings! They look a lot alike!

  40. berlin citylights says:

    lily wearing a captain marvel shirt – i stan one(1) person!

  41. berlin citylights says:

    riley immediately going with rhetts daughter bit had me laughing

  42. Elsie Dume says:

    Riley Rainstorm !

  43. deprofundis says:

    This episode reminded me why it's worth it to watch GMMore. So funny!

  44. Brian Powell says:

    You should do MREs for one of your show's you could even do one's from around the world

  45. Chris Sparks says:

    I bet half the comments on here are going to be about them cutting back to Link double dipping lol. But to be fair, he said he was going to before he actually did. But still lol. 🙂

  46. megan danbrook says:

    OMG Riley is hilarious. And Lily is so grown up! What happened to the little girl in the "My hair goes up" video

  47. Codey Stoudenmire says:

    We do Cinnamon Toast Crunch in Vanilla ice cream in this house 🤤 it’s amazing

  48. Donny Does says:

    Almond Honey bunches of oats on ice cream is the bees knees

  49. Jimmy Suwangsa says:

    well riley could really be Rhett's daughter

  50. Brandon Shetler says:


  51. It's just me ❤️ says:

    I enjoy when the crew reply to Rhett and Link's comments in the edits! They should do that more often!!

  52. No_ abe says:

    You looked great with that jedi tail! (scalp piercing)

  53. Amenhofis Ruiz says:

    Love the edits!!!!

  54. Tim Guzman says:

    They should make a show with Riley and Lily as correspondents or anchors in the field doing interviews.

  55. Georgia Day says:

    riley is so adorable

  56. Nate's Life says:

    Just saying. I want cotton candy randy to be a crossover event on the Dream Daddy game from the Game Grumps.

  57. Steve Rowley says:

    can you check to see if you have gold fever

  58. nunya bieeswax says:

    Wendy’s nuggets + a chocolate frosty = best creation

  59. PlayerOneGaming 333 says:

    Was I the only one who noticed that Rhett almost said Riley Reed? Lol

  60. Kahn says:

    Your daughter and her friend should have their own show

  61. Gazzy Ride says:

    They should get their own segment or episode. I think they are funny

  62. Ana Banana says:

    *Mixing cereals with icecream should be a new video idea!!*🍦

  63. KAngely 3613 says:

    This episode was brilliant!

  64. Ozmataz Groves says:

    That moment when Matt becomes my favorite gmm crew member.

  65. Peli Tongi says:

    I can understand the hot sauce on ice cream. I put hot sauce and or red pepper flakes on cake

  66. Hannah Van Kuiken says:

    What was Lily's reaction to Lando being on the show?

  67. _xris10 says:

    Lily has gotten so much older wtf

  68. Jake Kim says:


  69. Aida Denisa says:

    They so cute

  70. Moira Catherine says:

    These edits are the best haha

  71. Ricky Burden says:

    Almost all cereal is great in vanilla icecream!!!

  72. peaceful Fury says:

    Link! Rhett! You gotta go to Links daughters school for an awesome special guest day! You'll score so many awesome points!

  73. Vanessa Graves says:

    Yay I love Lily!

  74. Valerie Goff says:

    Lilly is good at this too!! She looks alittle bit like him lol

  75. Emily Batty says:

    When link double dipped I KNEW they would play that clip

  76. Megan G says:

    Yessss post expose him 😂

  77. Kanima Hammons says:

    Riley and Rhett
    Link and Lily
    But Rhett and Lily match
    And Link and Riley match
    Rhett and Lily have have similarly colored hair
    And Link and Riley both have glasses.

  78. Marilyne T. says:

    Mattew's comment at the bottom, im crying HAHAHAHA

  79. Logan S. says:

    "Hey do you want to like go to the mall tonight?"
    "I can't I have to go to work with my dad, smh. He said you could come though."
    "Isn't your dad like the host of a famous talk show though?"
    "Eh, I'm sure it won't be weird."

  80. Dale Trevors says:

    What's the big deal about a single hair, for real.

  81. Fathin Noor Aqilah Ariff says:

    Riley and lily are awesome.

  82. Moonbot 7 says:

    Nilla wafer with a mini marshmallow on it. Microwave for 10 secs and boom…great snack. Let it cool down but be sure to enjoy the marshmallow growing while microwaving

  83. Anna Villaneda says:

    Matthew is the vigilante we need

  84. Caroline Kridle says:

    My art teacher also had a fear of whales!

  85. Albino Cadillac says:

    I'm so happy that Lilly's here cause she's never here!

  86. Devyn Kellner says:

    I LOVE WHALES!!!!!!!!!!!!

  87. That_Freak_Kid says:

    Links kids act so similar like i would be able to tell they were siblings 😂

  88. Bret Fritz says:

    It was awesome to see how Lily was. I wonder how Locke and Lincoln are doing?

  89. Tooties McShmooties says:

    When did the kids stop homeschooling I wonder?

  90. Daniel Carter says:


  91. Sushi lover says:

    Have them take over the show for an episode

  92. Really Now says:

    Should drill Morgan, wow the phrasing of that

  93. Chris Samuels says:

    Have them on more they are good!!!

  94. Chris Samuels says:


  95. Jill Sanders says:

    I love Lily's t-shirt!!

  96. Jayson Davis says:

    1000 points to Matthew for bringing the laughs.

    I replayed the end 5 times just for Matthew hijacking the show.

  97. zny says:

    wait…how old are y'all 😂

  98. VK2532 says:

    Cereals in ice cream. Someone been to a Japanese maid cafe XD

  99. Nick Revine says:

    ew, links residue was in there

  100. Madi RoseT says:

    cinnamon toast crunch on vanilla ice cream is INCREDIBLE

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *